What To Do With Old Potatoes – Grow New Life Or Enrich Your Garden

ByRimon Chowdhury Updated on

Ah, the humble potato! We’ve all been there, haven’t we? You reach into the pantry, hoping to whip up a delicious meal, only to find your once firm, pristine potatoes have started to sprout enthusiastic eyes or have gone a little soft around the edges. It’s a common gardener’s dilemma and a question many of us ponder: what to do with old potatoes that are past their prime for eating?

Don’t despair! Before you toss them into the bin, know this: those seemingly “past it” spuds hold incredible potential. As an experienced gardener, I’m here to tell you that these potatoes are far from useless. In fact, they can be a fantastic resource for your garden, your compost pile, and even a few other surprising uses. You’re about to discover how to transform these forgotten tubers into new life, rich soil, and valuable resources.

In this comprehensive guide, we’ll explore everything from planting them to composting them sustainably, ensuring you make the most of every last potato. Get ready to turn a potential waste item into a garden triumph!

Revitalize Your Garden: Planting Old Potatoes for a Bountiful Harvest

One of the most exciting and rewarding answers to what to do with old potatoes is to plant them! Those sprouts, or “eyes,” are actually tiny shoots ready to grow into new potato plants. It’s a wonderfully sustainable way to get more food from what you already have. Let’s dive into the `how to what to do with old potatoes` when planting.

Choosing the Right “Seed” Potatoes

Not every old potato is a candidate for planting. Here’s what to look for:

  • Firmness: Ideally, your old potatoes should still be relatively firm. If they’re mushy, moldy, or smell bad, they’re not suitable for planting and should be discarded (or composted carefully, as we’ll discuss).
  • Sprouts: Look for potatoes with strong, healthy sprouts, about ½ to 1 inch long. These are often called “chitted” potatoes.
  • Disease-Free: Ensure there are no signs of disease like dark spots, unusual lesions, or fuzzy mold. Planting diseased potatoes can introduce problems to your garden soil.

For the best results, smaller potatoes (about egg-sized) can be planted whole. Larger potatoes can be cut into pieces, ensuring each piece has at least two healthy “eyes” and is about 1.5 to 2 ounces in weight. Allow cut pieces to “cure” for a day or two in a dry, warm spot before planting. This forms a protective skin, preventing rot.

Chitting Your Potatoes for Success

Chitting is a simple but effective technique that gives your potatoes a head start. It’s one of the best `what to do with old potatoes best practices` for planting.

  1. Gather Your Spuds: Select your firm, sprouting potatoes.
  2. Find a Cool, Bright Spot: Place them in an egg carton or a shallow tray, ensuring the most sprouts are facing upwards.
  3. Let Them Chit: Store them in a cool (around 50-60°F or 10-15°C), bright, but indirect light location for 2-4 weeks. This encourages short, stout, green sprouts rather than long, pale, weak ones that can develop in the dark.

These chitted potatoes are now primed and ready for planting, giving them a significant advantage once they hit the soil.

Planting Your Sprouted Treasures

Once your potatoes are chitted, it’s time to get them in the ground. This `what to do with old potatoes guide` for planting is straightforward:

  • Timing is Key: Plant after the last frost date in your area, when the soil has warmed up.
  • Prepare Your Soil: Potatoes love loose, well-draining soil rich in organic matter. Amend heavy clay soils with compost.
  • Dig Trenches or Hills: Dig trenches 6-8 inches deep, or prepare hills. Space potatoes 12-15 inches apart in rows 2-3 feet apart.
  • Planting Depth: Place whole small potatoes or potato pieces (cut side down) into the trench or hill.
  • Cover Gently: Cover with 3-4 inches of soil.

As the plants grow, you’ll “hill up” soil around the stems, covering more of the plant. This protects the developing tubers from sunlight (which can turn them green and inedible) and encourages more potatoes to form along the stem. This is crucial for a successful potato harvest.

Ongoing Care for Your New Potato Plants

To ensure a thriving harvest from your old potatoes, proper care is essential. Consider this your mini `what to do with old potatoes care guide` for new plants:

  • Watering: Potatoes need consistent moisture, especially during flowering and tuber development. Aim for 1-2 inches of water per week, either from rain or irrigation.
  • Fertilizing: If your soil isn’t rich, a balanced organic fertilizer can be applied when plants are about 6 inches tall, and again when they start to flower.
  • Pest and Disease Watch: Keep an eye out for common potato pests like Colorado potato beetles or signs of blight. Healthy plants are more resistant.
  • Hilling Up: Continue to mound soil around the growing plants every couple of weeks until they are about a foot tall, leaving the top 4-6 inches of foliage exposed.

You’ll typically harvest potatoes when the foliage begins to yellow and die back, usually 70-120 days after planting, depending on the variety.

READ MORE  When To Plant Sweet Potatoes In Mississippi – Your Ultimate Guide

Enriching Your Soil: Composting Old Potatoes the Eco-Friendly Way

If planting isn’t an option, or your old potatoes are too far gone, another fantastic and `sustainable what to do with old potatoes` is to compost them. This is an incredibly `eco-friendly what to do with old potatoes` solution that turns potential waste into nutrient-rich soil amendment.

Why Compost Old Potatoes?

Composting old potatoes offers several `benefits of what to do with old potatoes` for your garden:

  • Nutrient Recycling: Potatoes are full of organic matter and nutrients that, when broken down, enrich your soil structure and feed your plants.
  • Waste Reduction: Diverting food scraps from landfills reduces methane emissions, a potent greenhouse gas.
  • Improved Soil Health: Compost adds beneficial microbes, improves drainage, and increases water retention in your garden beds.

It’s a win-win for your garden and the planet!

Best Practices for Composting Potatoes

While composting potatoes is generally good, there are `what to do with old potatoes best practices` to follow:

  1. Cut Them Up: Chop larger potatoes into smaller pieces (2-3 inches). This speeds up decomposition.
  2. Bury Them Deep: Place potato pieces deep within your compost pile, covered by other “brown” materials like leaves or straw, and “green” materials like grass clippings. This helps prevent pests from being attracted and ensures they break down efficiently.
  3. Balance Your Pile: Remember the brown-to-green ratio. Potatoes are considered “greens” (nitrogen-rich), so balance them with plenty of “browns” (carbon-rich) to maintain a healthy, active compost pile.
  4. Turn Regularly: Turning your compost pile frequently introduces oxygen, which accelerates decomposition and helps maintain high temperatures that break down plant material effectively.

A hot, active compost pile is best, as it helps break down any potential potato pathogens and prevents the potatoes from sprouting in the pile itself.

What About Diseased Potatoes?

This is a `common problem with what to do with old potatoes` when considering composting. If your old potatoes show signs of disease (like late blight, scab, or fusarium dry rot), it’s generally best to avoid composting them in a home compost pile. Many common garden diseases can survive typical home composting temperatures and could spread to your garden when you use the finished compost.

For diseased potatoes, the safest option is to bag them and dispose of them in your regular household trash, preventing the spread of pathogens.

Beyond the Bin: Creative & Safe Uses for Old Potatoes

Even if planting or composting isn’t your chosen path, there are still a few clever `what to do with old potatoes tips` that can benefit your home and garden, provided they aren’t green, moldy, or excessively sprouted.

Feeding Your Livestock (Cautionary Notes)

For those with chickens, pigs, or other livestock, old potatoes can sometimes be a supplemental feed. However, this comes with strong caveats:

  • NEVER Feed Green Potatoes: Green parts of potatoes contain solanine, which is toxic to animals (and humans).
  • Cook Them: Raw potatoes can be difficult for some animals to digest. Boiling or steaming them first makes them safer and more palatable.
  • Moderation: Potatoes should only be a small part of an animal’s diet, not a staple.
  • Consult a Vet: Always check with a veterinarian or livestock expert before introducing new foods to your animals.

Due to the risks, this option is generally for experienced homesteaders who understand the specific dietary needs and tolerances of their animals.

DIY Garden Pest Repellent

Believe it or not, old potatoes can be used as a trap for certain garden pests. Cut slices of raw potato and place them in your garden beds overnight. Slugs, snails, and even wireworms are attracted to the potato. In the morning, you can collect the potato slices with the pests attached and dispose of them.

This is a natural, non-toxic method to help manage some common garden pests without chemicals.

Natural Cleaning Power

The starch in potatoes can be surprisingly effective for certain cleaning tasks! Here are a couple of `what to do with old potatoes tips` for natural cleaning:

  • Rust Removal: Cut a potato in half, sprinkle some salt or baking soda on the cut surface, and rub it on rusty items like cast iron pans or tools. The oxalic acid in the potato, combined with the abrasive, helps break down rust.
  • Silver Polishing: Boil some potato skins in water. Let the water cool, then soak tarnished silver items in it for an hour. The starch helps lift the tarnish. Polish with a soft cloth afterward.

These are great eco-friendly alternatives to harsh chemical cleaners!

Spotting the Danger: When Old Potatoes Are Truly Unsafe

While many old potatoes can be repurposed, it’s crucial to understand when they become a health hazard. This is a `common problem with what to do with old potatoes` that can have serious implications if ignored.

Understanding Solanine: The Green Potato Peril

Potatoes naturally produce compounds called glycoalkaloids, primarily solanine and chaconine. These compounds are a natural defense mechanism against pests and diseases. While present in small, harmless amounts in healthy potatoes, their levels can increase significantly under certain conditions:

  • Green Skin: Exposure to light causes potatoes to produce chlorophyll (which makes them green) and also triggers an increase in solanine. The green color itself isn’t toxic, but it’s a strong indicator of high solanine levels.
  • Sprouting: As potatoes sprout, solanine levels concentrate in the sprouts and the area around them.
  • Damage: Bruised or damaged potatoes can also have higher solanine levels.

Consuming high levels of solanine can lead to digestive upset (nausea, vomiting, diarrhea), headaches, and in severe cases, neurological problems. Always cut away green parts and sprouts before eating, and if a potato is significantly green or has numerous long sprouts, it’s best to discard it entirely from human consumption.

When to Discard: Mold, Strong Odor, and Excessive Sprouting

Beyond the solanine risk, here’s a clear `what to do with old potatoes guide` on when to say goodbye:

  • Mold: Any visible mold on a potato means it’s compromised. Mold can produce toxins that permeate the potato, even if you cut away the visible part. Discard it.
  • Mushy Texture: If a potato is completely soft, mushy, or slimy, it’s decaying and should be thrown out.
  • Foul Odor: A strong, unpleasant, or rotten smell is a definitive sign that the potato has spoiled and is unsafe for any use, including composting.
  • Excessive, Long Sprouts: While small sprouts are fine for planting, a potato covered in long, shriveled, or black sprouts often indicates very high solanine levels and significant nutrient depletion. It’s best to discard these.
READ MORE  Growing Potatoes In A Bucket - Your Expert Guide To A Bountiful,

When in doubt, throw it out! Your health and the health of your garden (if composting) are paramount.

Maximizing Your Harvest: Tips for Storing Potatoes to Prevent Spoilage

The best way to deal with old potatoes is to prevent them from getting old in the first place! Proper storage can significantly extend the shelf life of your potatoes. These `what to do with old potatoes tips` are really about proactive potato care.

The Ideal Storage Environment

Potatoes thrive in specific conditions:

  • Cool Temperatures: Store potatoes in a cool environment, ideally between 45-50°F (7-10°C). Temperatures much colder (like a refrigerator) can convert starch to sugar, affecting flavor and texture. Warmer temperatures encourage sprouting.
  • Darkness: Light exposure causes potatoes to turn green and increases solanine. Always store them in a dark place.
  • Good Ventilation: Potatoes need air circulation to prevent moisture buildup, which can lead to mold and rot. Don’t store them in sealed plastic bags. Baskets, paper bags, or burlap sacks are ideal.
  • Humidity: A moderate humidity level (around 85-95%) is good to prevent shriveling.

A cool, dark pantry, basement, or root cellar is often the perfect spot.

Avoiding Common Storage Mistakes

Many common household practices actually shorten potato shelf life:

  • Don’t Refrigerate: As mentioned, cold temperatures affect flavor and texture.
  • Keep Away from Onions: Onions and potatoes both release gases that can accelerate spoilage in the other. Store them separately.
  • Avoid Direct Sunlight: Even indirect light over time can cause greening.
  • Don’t Wash Before Storing: Washing removes the protective natural layer on the potato skin and introduces moisture, encouraging rot. Brush off excess dirt instead.

By following these `what to do with old potatoes best practices` for storage, you can enjoy your fresh potatoes for much longer and reduce the likelihood of having to deal with old, sprouting ones!

Frequently Asked Questions About What to Do with Old Potatoes

Can I eat potatoes with small sprouts?

Yes, usually. If the potato is firm and the sprouts are small, you can simply cut off the sprouts and any green areas before cooking. However, if the sprouts are numerous, long, or the potato is shriveled, it’s best to discard it for eating due to higher solanine levels.

How long can I store potatoes before they go bad?

Under ideal storage conditions (cool, dark, well-ventilated, 45-50°F), potatoes can last for several weeks to a few months. At room temperature, they will typically last 1-3 weeks before sprouting significantly.

Is it safe to plant potatoes that have turned green?

While greening indicates higher solanine, it doesn’t necessarily harm the plant’s ability to grow. However, for best results, it’s preferable to plant potatoes that are firm and have healthy, short sprouts, rather than those that are significantly green and soft. If you do plant green ones, ensure they are buried deep in the soil.

Can I compost cooked potatoes?

Yes, you can compost cooked potatoes, but ensure they are plain and free of oils, butter, or heavy sauces, which can attract pests and slow down decomposition. Chop them into small pieces and bury them deep in your compost pile.

What if my old potatoes are too small to cut into pieces for planting?

Small, egg-sized potatoes can be planted whole! Just ensure they are firm and have at least one or two healthy sprouts. This saves you the step of cutting and curing.

Conclusion

Who knew those neglected spuds in your pantry held so much potential? From bringing forth a new generation of delicious tubers to enriching your garden’s soil and even tackling household chores, there are so many valuable answers to the question of what to do with old potatoes.

Embracing these sustainable practices not only reduces waste but also deepens your connection to the gardening cycle. So, the next time you find a forgotten potato sprouting in the dark, don’t see it as waste. See it as an opportunity to grow, to nourish, and to get a little more creative in your garden and home.

Go forth, Greeny Gardener, and transform those old potatoes into something truly wonderful!

Rimon Chowdhury
Latest posts by Rimon Chowdhury (see all)

Similar Posts