Evergreen Trees To Avoid – A Gardener’S Guide To Preventing Costly

ByRimon Chowdhury Updated on

We’ve all been there. You’re standing at the local garden center, completely captivated by a row of beautiful, lush evergreen trees. They promise year-round color, a fast-growing privacy screen, and a touch of majestic structure for your landscape. It feels like the perfect, simple solution.

But what if I told you that some of the most commonly sold evergreens are ticking time bombs for your garden? It’s a hard lesson many gardeners (myself included!) learn too late. Making the wrong choice can lead to years of frustration, unexpected costs, and a landscape that looks nothing like you dreamed.

I promise this guide will help you sidestep those common pitfalls. We’re going to talk honestly about the popular evergreen trees to avoid and why they often cause more trouble than they’re worth. Think of me as your friendly garden mentor, here to share some hard-won wisdom.

In this complete evergreen trees to avoid guide, we’ll uncover the most problematic varieties, explore the issues they create, and most importantly, I’ll show you some fantastic, resilient alternatives that will bring you joy, not headaches, for years to come.

Why Choosing the Right Evergreen is Crucial for Your Garden’s Future

Planting a tree is a long-term commitment. Unlike a perennial you can move next season, a tree puts down deep roots and becomes a permanent fixture. The initial excitement of rapid growth can quickly turn into a massive problem if you’ve chosen the wrong species.

Understanding the benefits of evergreen trees to avoid from the start is one of the most important things you can do for your landscape. It’s not about hating these trees; it’s about acknowledging they are often misused and planted in places they simply don’t belong.

When you avoid problematic evergreens, you are also choosing to:

  • Save Time and Money: You’ll avoid the future costs of disease management, constant pruning, or even complete removal by an arborist, which can be incredibly expensive.
  • Protect Your Property: Trees with weak wood or invasive root systems can damage foundations, driveways, and sewer lines, or pose a risk during storms.
  • Create a Healthier Ecosystem: Choosing native or well-behaved non-native trees supports local wildlife and prevents the spread of invasive species. This is a core principle for creating a sustainable and eco-friendly evergreen trees to avoid strategy.
  • Reduce Maintenance: The right tree in the right place requires far less pruning, spraying, and general worry, giving you more time to simply enjoy your garden.

The Top 5 Problematic Evergreen Trees to Avoid

Alright, let’s get down to the specifics. Here are five of the most common offenders I see in home landscapes. I’ll explain exactly why they make this list and what you can plant instead for a much happier outcome. This is the core of our discussion on how to evergreen trees to avoid successfully.

1. Leyland Cypress (Cupressus × leylandii)

The Problem: This is the go-to “instant privacy” tree, and that’s precisely the issue. It grows incredibly fast—up to 3-4 feet per year—but this rapid growth comes at a cost. It quickly outgrows its space, becoming a monstrous, 60-foot-tall giant in just a couple of decades.

Its root system is notoriously shallow, making it unstable in high winds and storms. Worse, it’s highly susceptible to devastating diseases like Seiridium and Botryosphaeria canker, which can wipe out an entire hedge in a single season. Once it gets too tall, it’s nearly impossible to maintain.

A Better Choice: Plant ‘Green Giant’ Arborvitae (Thuja plicata ‘Green Giant’) instead. It’s also fast-growing but has a much stronger, more conical form, is far more disease-resistant, and handles trimming better. For a native option, consider the tough and adaptable Eastern Red Cedar (Juniperus virginiana).

2. Bradford Pear (Pyrus calleryana ‘Bradford’)

The Problem: While technically a deciduous tree, it’s often marketed for its dense, year-round screening effect when young and holds its leaves late into the season. But friends, please don’t plant this tree. Its branching structure is famously weak, leading to major splitting and breakage in wind, snow, or ice storms. I’ve seen countless Bradford Pears literally tear themselves in half.

READ MORE  Veggies That Grow Well Together: Your Practical Guide To A Thriving

Beyond its structural flaws, it’s an invasive species in many parts of the country, and its spring flowers, while pretty from a distance, emit a notoriously unpleasant odor. It’s a tree with a short, problematic lifespan.

A Better Choice: For beautiful spring flowers and a much stronger structure, plant a native Serviceberry (Amelanchier spp.) or a Black Gum (Nyssa sylvatica), which offers stunning fall color and is incredibly resilient.

3. Norway Spruce (Picea abies)

The Problem: There’s nothing inherently wrong with a Norway Spruce—in a park or on a large estate. The issue is that it’s often sold to homeowners with small suburban yards. This tree wants to be massive, easily reaching 80-100 feet tall with a 40-foot spread. It completely overwhelms small spaces.

Its dense lower branches kill all grass and perennials underneath it, and it constantly sheds needles, creating a thick, acidic mat on the ground. For most residential lots, it’s simply too much tree.

A Better Choice: If you love the spruce look, try the more slender Serbian Spruce (Picea omorika), which has a graceful, weeping habit and a much narrower footprint. The Dwarf Alberta Spruce (Picea glauca ‘Conica’) is a fantastic option for a small, conical accent that stays compact.

4. Austrian Pine (Pinus nigra)

The Problem: For the first 10 years, the Austrian Pine looks fantastic. It’s dense, a rich green, and grows quickly. Then, almost like clockwork, it begins to succumb to a host of fungal diseases, most notably Diplodia (Sphaeropsis) tip blight and Dothistroma needle blight.

These diseases cause the new growth to die back and the older needles to drop, leaving the tree looking sparse, sick, and unattractive. It’s a heartbreaking decline for a tree that started with so much promise. This is one of the most common problems with evergreen trees to avoid that I encounter.

A Better Choice: The native Eastern White Pine (Pinus strobus) is a beautiful, soft-needled alternative, though it also gets large. For tougher, salt-tolerant conditions, look to the Pitch Pine (Pinus rigida). Always check for disease-resistant cultivars at your local nursery.

5. Colorado Blue Spruce (Picea pungens) in the Wrong Climate

The Problem: That stunning, silvery-blue color is hard to resist. In its native Rocky Mountain habitat of cool, dry air and well-drained soil, it’s a magnificent tree. However, when planted in regions with hot, humid summers and heavy clay soil (like much of the Midwest, East, and South), it suffers.

Under these stressful conditions, it becomes highly vulnerable to Cytospora canker and Rhizosphaera needle cast, which cause the lower branches to die off, leaving a bare, ugly trunk with only a small tuft of blue at the top. It’s a classic “right plant, wrong place” scenario.

A Better Choice: For that beautiful blue-gray color in hotter, drier climates, plant an Arizona Cypress (Cupressus arizonica). In milder climates, the graceful Deodar Cedar (Cedrus deodara) offers a similar silvery, weeping look and is much more adaptable.

Sustainable and Eco-Friendly Evergreen Choices

One of the most important evergreen trees to avoid tips I can give you is to think sustainably. A sustainable landscape is one that is resilient, low-maintenance, and beneficial to the local environment. This means shifting our focus from fast-growing problem trees to those that are better suited for our specific region.

Here are some wonderful, more eco-friendly options to consider:

  • American Holly (Ilex opaca): A stunning broadleaf evergreen that provides beautiful red berries for winter interest and food for birds.
  • Canadian Hemlock (Tsuga canadensis): A graceful, soft-textured evergreen that thrives in partial shade. Just be sure to check for resistance to the woolly adelgid pest in your area.
  • Inkberry Holly (Ilex glabra): A fantastic native shrub that can be used for low hedges and foundation plantings, perfect for replacing boxwoods that can be prone to blight.
  • Virginia Pine (Pinus virginiana): A tough, adaptable native pine that is great for difficult sites and provides excellent habitat for wildlife.

Evergreen Trees to Avoid Best Practices: How to Choose Wisely

So, how do you avoid making a mistake at the nursery? It comes down to asking the right questions and doing a little homework. This is your ultimate evergreen trees to avoid best practices checklist.

  1. Know Your “Why”: What is the tree’s job? Is it for privacy, a focal point, or a windbreak? The function will help determine the right size and shape.
  2. Assess Your Site: How much sun does the spot get? Is the soil sandy, clay, or loamy? Is it wet or dry? Be brutally honest about your conditions. Don’t try to force a plant to grow where it doesn’t want to be.
  3. Think About Mature Size: This is the big one! Read the plant tag carefully. That cute little 3-foot spruce will one day be 60 feet tall. Measure your space and ensure it can accommodate the tree’s ultimate height and width. A good rule is to plant a tree at a distance of at least half its mature spread from your house foundation.
  4. Prioritize Native Plants: Native trees are adapted to your local climate, soil, and pests. They generally require less water, no fertilizer, and support local pollinators and wildlife, making them a cornerstone of sustainable evergreen trees to avoid practices.
  5. Ask About Disease Resistance: When talking to nursery staff, always ask if a particular variety is known for disease or pest problems in your area. They are an invaluable source of local knowledge.
READ MORE  Container Garden Soil Mix Recipe - Your Blueprint For Perfect Potted

Frequently Asked Questions About Evergreen Trees to Avoid

What is the messiest evergreen tree?

While “messy” can be subjective, many gardeners would point to the Norway Spruce. It sheds a tremendous amount of small, sharp needles that are difficult to rake and create acidic soil conditions, making it hard to grow anything underneath.

Are there any fast-growing evergreens that are NOT problematic?

Yes! The ‘Green Giant’ Arborvitae is a fantastic alternative to the Leyland Cypress. It grows quickly (2-3 feet per year) but is much more disease-resistant, has a stronger root system, and maintains a more manageable, uniform shape, requiring less pruning.

Why do people keep planting these problematic trees?

It often comes down to availability and instant gratification. These trees are mass-produced and grow quickly in a nursery pot, so they look full and appealing to buyers who want a fast solution for privacy. This is why following an evergreen trees to avoid care guide like this one is so important for making informed, long-term decisions.

How do I know if a tree is invasive in my area?

This is a great question! Your local cooperative extension office or state’s Department of Natural Resources will have a list of invasive plant species. You can also check the National Invasive Species Information Center (NISIC) website. Avoiding invasive species is key to being an eco-friendly gardener.

Planting with Confidence for a Beautiful Future

Choosing a tree for your garden should be a joyful experience, not a future liability. By understanding which evergreen trees to avoid and, more importantly, why they are problematic, you empower yourself to make a smarter, more sustainable choice.

Remember the golden rule of gardening: right plant, right place. Take the time to research, assess your space honestly, and choose a tree that is destined to thrive in your unique conditions. Your future self—and your beautiful, healthy, low-maintenance garden—will thank you for it.

Now go forth and plant with confidence!

Rimon Chowdhury
Latest posts by Rimon Chowdhury (see all)

Similar Posts