Chinese Money Plant Vs Jade Plant: Which Good Luck Plant Is Right For

ByRimon Chowdhury Updated on

Ever find yourself in a plant shop, caught between two iconic green beauties? On one side, the whimsical, coin-shaped leaves of the Chinese Money Plant. On the other, the sturdy, jewel-like foliage of the classic Jade Plant. Both are famous for bringing good fortune, but their personalities couldn’t be more different!

I get it. Choosing the right houseplant can feel like a big commitment. You want a plant that not only looks great but will actually thrive in your home without causing you a headache. It’s a common dilemma for so many plant lovers, and the fear of picking the “wrong” one is real.

But don’t you worry. In this complete chinese money plant vs jade plant guide, I’m going to share all my gardener’s secrets with you. We’ll break down everything—from their looks and light needs to common problems and how to share them with friends. By the end, you’ll feel confident and excited to choose the perfect green companion for your space.

At a Glance: Key Differences Between the Chinese Money Plant and Jade Plant

Before we dig into the soil, let’s get a quick overview. Think of this as the “speed dating” round for your future plant. While both are considered easy-care, their needs are distinct. Understanding these core differences is the first step in our chinese money plant vs jade plant guide.

Appearance & Growth Habit

  • Chinese Money Plant (Pilea peperomioides): Known for its unique, perfectly round, coin-like leaves that sit atop long, thin stems. It has a more delicate, whimsical look and grows by sending out little “pups” or offshoots from its base and roots.
  • Jade Plant (Crassula ovata): This is a true succulent with thick, fleshy, oval-shaped leaves. It grows a sturdy, woody stem that gives it a miniature tree-like appearance over time. It’s a symbol of resilience and longevity.

Light & Water Needs

  • Chinese Money Plant: Prefers bright, indirect light. Direct sun will scorch its delicate leaves. It likes its soil to be consistently moist but never soggy.
  • Jade Plant: A sun-worshipper! It thrives in several hours of direct sunlight each day. As a succulent, it stores water in its leaves and needs its soil to dry out completely between waterings.

Pet Safety

  • Chinese Money Plant: Great news for pet owners! The Pilea is non-toxic to cats and dogs, making it a worry-free choice for homes with furry friends.
  • Jade Plant: A word of caution. The Jade Plant is mildly toxic to cats and dogs if ingested, potentially causing stomach upset. It’s best kept out of reach of curious pets.

Meet the Contenders: A Closer Look at Each Plant

Now that you have the highlights, let’s get properly introduced. Knowing a plant’s backstory and personality helps you connect with it and understand its needs on a deeper level.

The Charming Chinese Money Plant (Pilea peperomioides)

Often called the “Pancake Plant” or “UFO Plant,” the Pilea is a showstopper. Its charm lies in its minimalist, almost graphic appearance. Each leaf is a perfect circle, creating a playful and modern vibe.

This plant is a fantastic communicator. Its leaves will droop slightly to tell you it’s thirsty and perk right back up after a drink. One of the most rewarding benefits of chinese money plant vs jade plant ownership is watching the Pilea produce babies, or “pups,” which you can easily separate and share. It’s truly the plant that keeps on giving!

The Timeless Jade Plant (Crassula ovata)

The Jade Plant is a classic for a reason. With the right care, this plant can live for decades, becoming a treasured family heirloom passed down through generations. Its robust, tree-like structure adds a sense of grounding and stability to any room.

As a succulent, it’s incredibly forgiving if you forget to water it now and then. In fact, it prefers a little neglect! Its deep green, glossy leaves can sometimes develop a beautiful red tinge on the edges when exposed to plenty of direct sun, adding another layer of beauty.

The Ultimate Chinese Money Plant vs Jade Plant Care Guide

Alright, let’s get our hands dirty! This is where we break down the nitty-gritty of care. Following these chinese money plant vs jade plant best practices will set you up for success, no matter which plant you choose.

READ MORE  Pilea Peperomioides Leaves Curling Inward - An Expert Gardener'S

Lighting: Sun-Worshipper vs. Bright Shade Lover

This is the most critical difference. Getting the light right is 90% of the battle!

For your Chinese Money Plant, think bright but gentle. An east-facing window that gets soft morning sun is perfect. A spot a few feet back from a sunny south or west-facing window also works. If the leaves start looking scorched or yellow, it’s getting too much direct sun.

Your Jade Plant, on the other hand, craves the sun. It needs at least four to six hours of direct sunlight per day to maintain its compact shape and vibrant color. A south-facing window is its happy place. If a Jade Plant doesn’t get enough light, it will become “leggy”—stretching out with lots of space between the leaves.

Watering: The “Drench and Dry” vs. “Consistently Moist” Method

Overwatering is the number one killer of houseplants, so listen closely!

The Jade Plant follows the classic succulent watering rule: the “drench and dry” method. When you do water, water it thoroughly until it runs out of the drainage hole. Then, and this is the important part, let the soil dry out completely before watering again. This could be every 2-4 weeks, depending on the season and your home’s humidity.

The Chinese Money Plant is a bit thirstier. It doesn’t want to dry out completely. A good rule of thumb is to water when the top 1-2 inches of soil feel dry to the touch. It wants to stay evenly moist, but never sitting in a puddle of water, which leads to root rot.

Soil and Potting: Building the Perfect Foundation

The right soil is crucial for drainage and aeration. For a truly sustainable chinese money plant vs jade plant setup, consider using peat-free soil mixes.

Your Jade Plant needs a gritty, fast-draining mix. A store-bought cactus or succulent soil is perfect. You can also make your own by mixing standard potting soil with perlite or coarse sand to improve drainage.

Your Chinese Money Plant is happy in a standard, high-quality potting mix. To make it even better, add a handful of perlite or orchid bark. This creates air pockets, keeping the roots happy and preventing the soil from becoming too compacted—an excellent eco-friendly chinese money plant vs jade plant tip!

Common Problems with Chinese Money Plant vs Jade Plant (And How to Fix Them!)

Even the best plant parents run into issues. Don’t panic! Here’s how to troubleshoot some common problems you might encounter.

Troubleshooting Your Chinese Money Plant

  • Curling Leaves: This is often a sign of either too much direct light or inconsistent watering. Check your light source first! If that’s okay, try to be more consistent with your watering schedule.
  • Yellowing Lower Leaves: It’s normal for the oldest, lowest leaves to occasionally turn yellow and drop off. However, if multiple leaves are yellowing at once, it’s likely a sign of overwatering. Let the soil dry out more between drinks.
  • White Spots on Leaves: Seeing tiny white dots on the underside of the leaves? Don’t worry, it’s not a pest! These are mineral deposits being secreted through the pores. It’s harmless, but you can switch to filtered or distilled water if it bothers you.

Solving Jade Plant Woes

  • Shriveled, Wrinkled Leaves: This is your Jade Plant’s clear signal that it’s thirsty. Give it a deep, thorough watering, and the leaves should plump back up within a day or two.
  • Mushy Stem or Dropping Leaves: This is the dreaded sign of root rot from overwatering. If the base is mushy, the plant may be hard to save. Immediately stop watering, and if possible, remove it from the pot to check the roots. Cut away any black, mushy roots and repot in fresh, dry succulent soil.
  • Leggy Growth: As mentioned, this means your plant is desperately stretching for more light. Move it to a much sunnier spot to encourage more compact, healthy growth.

Propagation Fun: Sharing the Wealth!

One of the great joys of owning these plants is how easy they are to propagate. It’s a wonderful way to create new plants for free and share them with friends and family.

Propagating Pilea “Pups”

Your Pilea will do most of the work for you by sending up little plantlets from the soil. Once a pup is about 2-3 inches tall, you can separate it.

  1. Use a clean, sharp knife to cut the pup’s connecting root about an inch below the soil line.
  2. You can place the new cutting directly into a small pot with soil or let it root in a glass of water first.
  3. Keep the soil lightly moist, and you’ll have a new, independent plant in no time!
READ MORE  How Often To Fertilize Pilea Peperomioides - Your Complete Seasonal

Propagating Jade Cuttings

Jade plants can be propagated from a single leaf or a stem cutting.

  1. Gently twist off a healthy leaf or use clean scissors to take a 3-4 inch stem cutting.
  2. Here’s the key: let the cutting sit out in a dry place for a few days until the cut end forms a callus. This prevents it from rotting.
  3. Once callused, simply place the cutting on top of dry succulent soil (or stick the stem cutting into the soil). Don’t water it!
  4. Wait a few weeks. It will start to grow tiny roots. Once you see roots, you can begin watering it very lightly, just like a mature Jade Plant.

Frequently Asked Questions About Chinese Money Plant vs Jade Plant

Which is easier for a total beginner, a Chinese Money Plant or a Jade Plant?

Honestly, both are fantastic beginner plants! However, the Jade Plant is slightly more forgiving, especially if you tend to forget to water your plants. Its succulent nature means it can handle a bit of neglect much better than the thirstier Chinese Money Plant.

Are Chinese Money Plants and Jade Plants toxic to pets?

This is a crucial distinction! The Chinese Money Plant (Pilea) is non-toxic and safe for homes with cats and dogs. The Jade Plant (Crassula) is mildly toxic and can cause vomiting and lethargy if ingested by pets, so it should be kept out of their reach.

Why are my Chinese Money Plant’s leaves drooping?

Drooping is almost always a sign of thirst. It’s your Pilea’s way of telling you it’s ready for a drink! Check the soil, and if the top inch or two is dry, give it a good watering. The leaves should perk back up within a few hours. It’s a very dramatic but helpful signal!

Can I grow a Jade Plant in a low-light apartment?

Unfortunately, a Jade Plant will not thrive in low light. It needs several hours of direct sun to stay healthy and compact. If you have a low-light space, a Chinese Money Plant would be a much better choice between the two, though even it needs bright, indirect light to do well.

So, Which Lucky Plant Will You Choose?

We’ve compared their looks, dived deep into their care needs, and even learned how to solve their problems. When it comes to the chinese money plant vs jade plant debate, there’s no single winner—only the right plant for you and your home.

If you have a bright, sunny window and a “less is more” approach to watering, the resilient and timeless Jade Plant is your perfect match. It will grow with you for years, becoming a beautiful, tree-like specimen.

If you have a spot with bright, indirect light and enjoy a more interactive watering routine, the playful and modern Chinese Money Plant will bring a unique charm to your space—and provide you with plenty of pups to share!

Whichever you welcome into your home, you’re not just getting a piece of decor; you’re gaining a living, breathing companion. Trust your instincts, consider your space, and get ready to enjoy the journey. Happy growing!

Rimon Chowdhury
Latest posts by Rimon Chowdhury (see all)

Similar Posts